Insurance Policy Review Checklists
Nine free, printable checklists for reviewing every major insurance policy you carry — annual review, renewal prep, and one for each policy type. No account required. Open the page, print, or save as PDF.
The fastest way to find out whether you’re paying for the right insurance is to read the declarations page of every policy you own and compare it against your current situation. These checklists walk you through what to look for, organized by policy type.
This content is educational and is not legal, financial, or insurance advice. Coverage decisions depend on your specific situation, risk tolerance, and the actual policy contract you’re offered. For a binding recommendation, speak with a licensed insurance agent in your state, or contact your state Department of Insurance.
Annual Insurance Review
- 1Pull the declarations page for every policy you carry (auto, home/renters, life, umbrella, business, etc.)
- 2List the named insureds, vehicles, properties, and dependents on each — confirm every person, asset, and address is still correct
- 3Confirm coverage limits, deductibles, and any endorsements/riders match what you remember buying
- 4Compare current premium to last year's premium — note the percentage change and ask the insurer to explain any increase
- 5Check whether you've added or removed assets (vehicle, teen driver, home renovation, business equipment) that should change coverage
- 6Review claim history on file (CLUE for auto/home) and dispute any incorrect entries
- 7Confirm beneficiaries on life and accident policies are up to date — especially after marriage, divorce, birth, or death
- 8Compare against 2–3 quotes for the same coverage limits — not lower limits — at least every 2 years
- 9Save copies of all policies and the declarations page to a cloud folder you control
Renewal Prep
- 1Read the renewal notice for any non-renewal warnings, rate changes, or coverage changes
- 2Confirm the renewed coverage limits and deductibles match what you currently have — insurers can change them silently
- 3Check whether new exclusions or endorsements were added (especially wind/hail, water backup, dog breed, roof ACV)
- 4Confirm any discounts you previously had are still listed (multi-policy, paid-in-full, paperless, good driver, alumni, etc.)
- 5Compare the renewal premium to two fresh quotes for identical coverage — not lower coverage — before paying
- 6If you're switching carriers, time the start/stop dates so there is no overlap and no gap
- 7Cancel the old policy in writing and keep the cancellation confirmation
Auto Policy Review
- 1Liability limits: confirm BI per-person, BI per-accident, and PD limits are appropriate for your assets — not just your state minimum
- 2Uninsured/underinsured motorist limits: ideally matching your liability limits
- 3PIP / MedPay if your state offers them — confirm amount
- 4Deductibles on comprehensive and collision — and whether you have a separate glass deductible
- 5Rental reimbursement coverage limit and per-day cap (often the per-day limit is too low for a real rental)
- 6Roadside / towing coverage — check whether you're already covered through a credit card or AAA before paying twice
- 7Gap coverage if the vehicle is financed or leased
- 8Named drivers — confirm every regular driver is listed and that no one is excluded that shouldn't be
- 9Telematics/usage-based program: are you in it, is it still saving money, can you opt out at renewal
- 10Discounts: multi-vehicle, multi-policy, good student, defensive driver course, paid-in-full, paperless
Home Policy Review
- 1Coverage A (dwelling) limit: does it match current rebuild cost — not market value, not original purchase price
- 2Coverage B (other structures): adequate for detached garage, shed, fence, pool equipment
- 3Coverage C (personal property): replacement cost or actual cash value — and any special limits (jewelry, firearms, electronics)
- 4Coverage D (loss of use / ALE): enough months of expenses if your home is uninhabitable
- 5Coverage E (personal liability) limit — typically should match umbrella underlying requirement
- 6Coverage F (medical payments to others)
- 7Wind/hail deductible — flat-dollar or percentage of dwelling limit
- 8Hurricane/named-storm deductible (FL, TX, NC, SC, LA, MS, AL, GA gulf/coast)
- 9Roof coverage: replacement cost vs ACV / roof-age schedule
- 10Ordinance or law endorsement
- 11Water backup of sewers and drains endorsement
- 12Service line coverage
- 13Equipment breakdown endorsement
- 14Scheduled personal property (engagement ring, art, instruments) with appraisal on file
- 15Flood policy (NFIP or private) — separately, with sufficient building + contents coverage
Life Policy Review
- 1Beneficiaries — primary and contingent — current and correctly identified
- 2Coverage amount vs current DIME calculation (debt + income replacement + mortgage + education)
- 3Policy type — term, whole, universal, IUL — and what happens at end of term or in a down market
- 4For term: years remaining; whether convertible to permanent without underwriting; conversion deadline
- 5For permanent: cash value, current crediting rate, COI charges, loan balance, surrender charge schedule
- 6Premium amount and whether premium is level for the entire term
- 7Riders: waiver of premium (disability), accelerated death benefit, child rider, accidental death — keep or drop
- 8Employer group life — coverage amount, portability if you leave, whether it's enough on its own (usually not)
- 9Whether you have any contestability period concerns from misstatements at application
Health & Medicare Review
- 1Network — confirm your doctors, specialists, hospitals, and pharmacy are in-network for the upcoming plan year
- 2Formulary — confirm every prescription medication is covered and at what tier
- 3Deductible, copays, coinsurance, and out-of-pocket maximum (in-network and out-of-network)
- 4Prior authorization requirements for ongoing medications or scheduled procedures
- 5Mental health, maternity, fertility coverage if relevant
- 6HSA eligibility (HDHP only) and family vs self-only contribution limits
- 7For Medicare: Part D plan formulary check during AEP (Oct 15 – Dec 7) — drug lists change every year
- 8Medicare Advantage: confirm doctors, hospitals, and supplemental benefits (dental, vision, OTC, gym) for new plan year
- 9Medigap: rate increase notification — and whether you can switch carriers (state rules vary)
- 10IRMAA bracket if income changed (especially after retirement, large Roth conversion, or Social Security start)
Renters Policy Review
- 1Coverage C (personal property) limit — typically too low at default; do a quick inventory to validate
- 2Replacement cost vs actual cash value — replacement cost is worth the small premium difference for most renters
- 3Liability limit — should be high enough to protect your assets and meet umbrella underlying requirement
- 4Loss of use coverage if you can't live in the rental
- 5Special limits — jewelry, electronics, bikes, instruments
- 6Off-premises coverage — for items stolen from a car or while traveling
- 7Earthquake / flood — usually excluded; add separately if your area is at risk
- 8Roommate coverage — confirm policy covers all named insureds or that each roommate has their own
Umbrella Policy Review
- 1Coverage amount — compare the umbrella limit you can buy against your household net worth, and ask what each additional layer of coverage costs
- 2Required underlying limits — confirm your auto BI, home PL, and renters PL all meet the umbrella's minimum (the Insurance Information Institute says most insurers want about $250,000 of liability on your auto policy and $300,000 on your homeowners policy before selling an umbrella)
- 3Excluded activities — business use, rental property, certain dog breeds, recreational vehicles
- 4Carrier — best practice is umbrella from same carrier as primary policies for fewer coverage gaps
- 5Net worth vs coverage amount — coverage should at least equal household net worth and ideally exceed it
- 6Lifestyle exposures since last review — teen driver added, dog adopted, pool installed, public profile, started a side business
Business Policy Review
- 1General liability limits — per-occurrence and aggregate
- 2Property coverage — building, business personal property, equipment, inventory at correct replacement values
- 3Business interruption / loss of income — number of months covered
- 4Professional liability (E&O) — claims-made vs occurrence, retroactive date, prior acts coverage
- 5Cyber liability — first-party (your costs) and third-party (your customers' costs)
- 6Workers' compensation — class codes, payroll estimates, audit-readiness
- 7Commercial auto — vehicles, drivers, business use; do not rely on personal auto for business use
- 8EPLI — employment practices liability if you have employees
- 9Hired & non-owned auto if employees ever drive personal vehicles for work
- 10Equipment breakdown / mechanical breakdown
- 11Inland marine for tools, mobile equipment, scheduled items
- 12Certificates of insurance — additional insured endorsements for client contracts
- 13Industry-specific endorsements (liquor liability, kitchen comp, contractor's E&O, etc.)
Print or save as PDF
Use your browser’s print function (Ctrl/Cmd+P) to print the checklist or save it as a PDF. Most browsers will preserve the numbered formatting. No file is downloaded from our servers — this is a static page.
Related tools
Sources: umbrella underlying-liability expectations from the Insurance Information Institute, What is an umbrella liability policy?
Important Disclaimer
This site provides general educational information only and is not a substitute for professional insurance advice. All rates, data, and coverage details are estimates and may not reflect your actual premiums. Insurance availability and pricing vary by state, insurer, and individual risk factors. Always consult a licensed insurance professional in your state before making coverage decisions.